The home belonging to James and Mary Kingsbury has been missing since 1917. In fact, it has been gone longer than it ever stood on what is today the northeast corner of Lowell and Bolton Avenues. James G. Kingsbury, the editor and publisher of the Indiana Farmer, a publication for Hoosiers involved in the agricultural and horticultural business, moved his large family into 5860 Lowell Avenue in 1886 or 1887. We do not know if they were the first owners of the grand Italianate home, but they lived in the residence until 1903. The family also owned a 28-acre farm behind the house on what is today North Bolton and Campbell Avenues.
Long before he moved to Irvington, James G. Kingsbury had likely known about the community as he was very involved in the Prohibition Party along with one of the founders of Irvington, Sylvester Johnson. Many of his children also attended Butler University. One of his sons, James L. Kingsbury moved to the area one year before his father and settled along Layman Avenue. Irvington's "dry" laws likely appealed to Mr. Kingsbury as well.
In total, James G. Kignsbury had four wives. His first wife, Mary Layman Kingsbury died before he moved to Irvington. Not long after relocating, Mary Taylor Kingsbury, his second wife, died at the young age of 43 on August 5, 1888. A year later, James G. Kingsbury married Kate Gunckel of Cincinnati on September 4, 1889. She lived long enough to move with him from his lovely home on Lowell Avenue to another residence on Layman Avenue. Only his fourth and final wife, Anna Graham Risk Kingsbury, outlived him.
When a census taker arrived at 5860 Lowell Avenue in 1900, he found a very full house. Besides 68-year-old James G. Kingsbury and 61-year-old Kate Gunckel Kingsbury, the enumerator also noted 25-year-old Charles Kingsbury, a son, who worked with the telephone company; 21-year-old Howard Kingsbury, who worked as a railroad clerk; 20-year-old John Fletcher Kingsbury, who served as a mechanic; and 13-year-old Theodore Kingsbury, who was still in school. Mr. Kingsbury also welcomed his former mother-in-law, 84-year-old Jane B. Taylor and his 22-year-old step daughter, Edna Gunckel into the home. Miss Gunckel worked as a proofreader. A 20-year-old servant named Lena Funke and her 2-year-old son, Edgar Funke also boarded in the house.
In an interview with a reporter for the Indianapolis News in 1903, Mr. Kingsbury noted that he had created a model farm and had hoped that one of his seven sons would take over the business; however, none of them were interested so he sold the house and the land to Willis Wright of Terre Haute, Indiana. The Kingsburys held one final reunion in the residence on July 3, 1903. After their departure, many people moved in and out of the house until W.H. Cooper applied for a permit to demolish the structures in 1917. Fascinatingly, Josephine Hyde Woodbury, pioneering female developer, purchased the farm and created a new subdivision called "Edgehill." A beautiful brick American Foursquare home was built for the Lewis family on the site of the former Kingsbury home in 1920.
 |
The Kingsbury home at 5860 Lowell Avenue c1895 (photo courtesy of the Kingsbury family)
|
 |
| Kingsbury home at 5860 Lowell Avenue c1895 (photo courtesy of the Kingsbury family) |
 |
| 5860 Lowell Avenue c1900 (courtesy of the Kingsbury family) |
 |
The Kingsbury home at 5860 Lowell Avenue can be seen on this 1889 map of Irvington. The residence and barn are located just next to "89" on this map. You will note that Bolton Avenue north of Lowell Avenue did not exist yet. Pleasant street, denoted in a dotted line, was never built. . (Irvington Historical Society)
|
 |
| James G. Kingsbury created a model farm behind his house at 5860 Lowell Avenue. He can be seen here c1895. The farm stretched up to Pleasant Run stream and over to Arlington Avenue. (photo courtesy of the Kingsbury family) |
 |
| "Kendall," a farm hand, (far left) stood near Nathan Howard (Punk) Kingsbury, Theodore Kingsbury, and John Fletcher (Butch) Kingsbury. Charles Kingsbury stood next to Billy the horse c1892. (photo courtesy of the Kingsbury Family) |
 |
| James G. Kingsbury, the Secretary of the Indiana Farmer, kept an office for the publication on the grounds of the Indiana State Fair. (photo courtesy of the Kingsbury family) |
 |
| Site of former Kingsbury home on June 23, 2025 |
Up Next: The Intersection of Lowell and Layman Avenues in the Early 20th Century
I wish to thank Kathy and Dick Meyer for the stories and use of the photographs from the Kingsbury family. Kathy is a descendant of James G. and Mary Taylor Kingsbury.
Sources: Polk's Indianapolis City Directories, 1886-1918; US Federal Census Records, 1880, 1900, 1910; Interview with Kathy and Dick Meyer, June 9, 2025; Kingsbury family in the 1880s: "Personal Mention," Indianapolis Journal, May 27, 1884, p. 3; "Death of Mrs. Kingsbury," Indianapolis Journal, August 7, 1888; "Personal and Society," Indianapolis Journal, September 5, 1889, p. 7; Prohibition Work: "Articles of Association," Indianapolis Journal, January 17, 1885, p. 7; "The City in Brief," Indianapolis Journal, November 10, 1885, p. 8; "Prohibitionist Satisfied," Indianapolis Journal, December 21, 1889, p. 1; Agricultural work: Indiana Farmer and agricultural work: "The Agricultural Board," Indianapolis Journal, January 8, 1885, ; "In Brief," Indianapolis Journal, June 10, 1887, p. 8; Buying and selling house: "Personal," Indianapolis News, June 11, 1887, p. 2; "Movement in Real Estate," Indianapolis Journal, May 27, 1888, p. 5; "Real Estate Transfers," Indianapolis Journal, October 31, 1889, p. 7; "Model Fruit Farm Sold," Indianapolis News, July 4, 1903, p. 24; "Twenty-Seven Transfers Made Matter of Record Yesterday," Indianapolis Journal, August 4, 1903, p. 8; Demolition--"Building Permits," Indianapolis Star, November 7, 1917; Edgehill--"Edghill in Irvington," Indianapolis News, June 21, 1919, p. 3.
