Thursday, May 29, 2025

Historic Glass Negatives See the Light


     In 1965, Richard and Colleen Wilson moved into 68 North Ritter Avenue. Under the basement stairs the couple discovered a soap crate filled with several hundred historic glass negatives. The family kept the artifacts for years and then donated the collection to the Irvington Historical Society in 2012.

     After receiving a grant, members of the Irvington Historical Society scanned all 338 images.  Director, Steve Barnett, determined that the photos belonged to Osbert Sumner, who lived at the Ritter Avenue home from 1904 until his death in 1932. Over the next decade researchers thoroughly examined each photograph. A major breakthrough occurred in 2022, when local researcher Deedee Davis discovered a Sumner family diary at the Oakville, Ontario Historical Society. Osbert Sumner originally lived in that town before moving to Indianapolis. The diary provided key entries that helped unlock many of the mysteries of the collection.

     Mr. Sumner's photographs contains incredible documentation of life in Canada and Indianapolis from 1899 to 1903. His subjects included family members and friends, canoe outings, parades, a convention, and even the funeral of President Benjamin Harrison. Some of the photos had been developed, but many will now be seen for the first time in over 125 years.

     To see these incredible photos in person, visit the Bona Thompson Center at 5350 University Avenue in Indianapolis. The collection will be on display from May 31 until November 16, 2025. We are open on the weekends from 1-4PM.  I have included a small sample below. 



Osbert Sumner photographed an unidentified girl on the steps leading to the Benton Home at 312 South Downey Avenue in Irvington. He most likely took the photo on July 4, 1901. He attended a celebration there. 


George Sumner, the father of Osbert Sumner, kept a diary. From one of his entries, we know that this photo was likely taken on October 10, 1900 in downtown Indianapolis. The elder Sumner, who lived in Oakville, Ontario, was visiting his family here. The city hosted a "Fall Carnival" complete with temporary ornamental arches leading into Monument Circle. 

Osbert Sumner captured a fallen cyclist in the Morton Place neighborhood of Indianapolis near the intersection of East 19th and North Delaware Streets. Note the beautiful esplanade that used to be in the middle of the street c1900. 

Osbert Sumner (1872-1932) received a camera as a gift from his fellow co-workers in 1898. For the next several years, he documented life in Indianapolis and back in his hometown of Oakville, Ontario. He loved the outdoors and many of his photos show excursions in canoes on various waterways in central Indiana. 

Tuesday, April 15, 2025

The Teeguardens Moved Into Newly-Built Home in Christian Park

Teeguarden family at 4621 Young Avenue: Joseph and Miriam (top) along with Bethanyanne and Linda, June, 1945 (photo courtesy of Dan Carlson)

 

     In January of 1942 both the Indianapolis Star and the Indianapolis News advertised that a newly-built home at 4621 Young Avenue in the recently-developed Christian Park Heights neighborhood was on the market for $4400. Beginning in 1941, the Grinslade Company built dozens of two and three-bedroom homes in the Christian Park neighborhood just west of Irvington. They had already sold 45 homes by the time they completed their newest property at 4621 Young Avenue. 

     Joseph R. and Miriam Teeguarden had been renting homes on Keystone and Kealing Avenues since their marriage in 1935. Mr. Teeguarden worked as a pressman for the Indianapolis News when the ad appeared.  The couple had been saving their money thanks in large part to Miriam Teeguarden, who was very adept at managing money with few resources. Shortly after the ad appeared, the Teeguardens along with their daughters, Bethanyanne and Linda, moved into the cottage in 1942.

     The Teeguardens represented the typical family who moved into the new addition as they were young and had children. In fact, there were so many young residents in the neighborhood that school officials struggled to accommodate the influx at nearby Christian Park Elementary School. (School #82) 

     As the United States joined the fight during World War II, Mr. Teeguarden worked stateside for the Lukas Harold Company manufacturing the Norden Bombsight. Once the war ended, he resumed his employment with the local newspapers. He was an avid tennis player and belonged to several organizations like the Jaycees. Mrs. Teeguarden stayed home and raised their two daughters. Her grandson notes that she kept a beautiful house and garden. Sometime in 1945 the couple painted their white house gray. Newspaper accounts indicate that Mrs. Teeguarden was highly involved with the Central Christian Church north of downtown Indianapolis. The couple also attended many plays and discussions at the Civic Theater. 

     The Teeguardens placed their home on the market in the fall of 1948 for $9400. They sold their home to another young family, the Tolers, and moved to the north side of the city. Photos from the Teeguarden family scrapbook show typical domestic scenes from the era. 

Indianapolis Star, January 25, 1942, p. 28


Bethanyanne, Joseph, and Linda Teeguarden at 4621 Young Avenue, September, 1943 (photo courtesy of Dan Carlson)

Linda and Bethanyanne Teeguarden, Christmas, 1943 at 4621 Young Avenue (photo courtesy of Dan Carlson) 

Linda and Bethanyanne Teeguarden posed in front of their home at 4621 Young Avenue in February of 1944. In the following year, the family painted the house gray. (photo courtesy of Dan Carlson)

Miriam Giddens Teeguarden (1917-1967) posed inside of her home at 4621 Young Avenue in 1944. Note the incredible radio next to her. (photo courtesy of Dan Carlson) 

Linda and Bethanyanne Teeguarden posed in their home at 4621 Young Avenue in 1944. (photo courtesy of Dan Carlson)

Linda and Bethanyanne Teeguarden on their front stoop at 4621 Young Avenue in 1944 (photo courtesy of Dan Carlson)

Easter portrait of Linda and Bethanyanne Teeguarden at 4621 Young Avenue in 1944 (photo courtesy of Dan Carlson)

The Teeguarden sisters posed next to 4621 Young Avenue on their first day of school in 1945. (photo courtesy of Dan Carlson)

The Teeguarden family sat for this portrait in the living room at their home of 4621 Young Avenue in 1945. Pictured: Miriam, Linda, Bethanyanne, and Joseph Teeguarden (photo courtesy of Dan Carlson)

Miriam Teeguarden posed with her daughter, Linda, along the front walk leading to their house at 4621 Young Avenue. Behind the women, you can see 4617 and 4613 Young Avenue. (photo courtesy of Dan Carlson) 

Linda and Bethanyanne Teeguarden in front of 4621 Young Avenue in 1947 (photo courtesy of Dan Carlson)

Bethanyanne Teeguarden on her front yard at 4621 Young Avenue in 1948 (photo courtesy of Dan Carlson)

Linda Teeguarden posed in front of her home at 4621 Young Avenue in the summer of 1948. If you look closely, you can see neighbors on their front stoop next door at 4625 Young Avenue. Vassel and Maxine Flinn lived in that home. (photo courtesy of Dan Carlson)


     I wish to thank Dan Carlson, the grandson of Joseph and Miriam Teeguarden and the son of Linda Teeguarden, for his stories and photographs. 

Sources:  Emails from Dan Carlson, 2025; Indianapolis City Directories 1940-1950; For Sale Ad--Indianapolis Star, November 4, 1948. p. 35; Patrons of Civic Theater--Indianapolis Star, March 8, 1946, p. 6; Obituary Miriam Teeguarden--"Mrs. Teeguarden Dies; Funeral to be Today," Indianapolis Star, January 12, 1967, p. 50. 

Saturday, March 15, 2025

Butler's Irvington Campus Only Had One Dorm

 

Butler Dorm, c1915 (photo courtesy of Kyle Kingen)
    

     Throughout its tenure from 1875 until 1928, Butler University only hosted one dormitory for students. Located in the northern part of the campus, the dormitory was completed in August of 1882. College officials awarded the architectural contract to brothers, Allen and John Stem. While both men went on to distinguished careers, the dorm at Butler would not be one of their better projects. It did not help that a tornado struck the area in the summer of 1882 felling many trees and damaging part of the building still under construction. 

     Butler historian George Waller recorded that the structure was poorly-built. Originally, men lived on one side of the building while women lived on the other side with a wall separating the sexes. Waller noted that holes appeared in that wall. Campus officials then decreed that only men would live in the building, but completely reversed course by the early twentieth century and made it the women's residence. 

     In the 1890s students rented the upper rooms for thirty cents a week while the lower floors leased for fifty cents a week. Students were expected to keep their rooms clean or to hire someone to clean it. Waller noted that the college furnished each room with a "bed, mattress, stove, table, chairs, and a washstand."  University officials also provided a "dorm cow" who was not to be "surreptitiously milked." By the 1910s those same rooms rented between $3.75 and $4.00 a week. 

     Despite growing enrollments and the arrival of the Christian Women's Board of Missions, the campus did not provide another dorm. Young men and some young women found rooms in nearby boarding houses or in fraternities or sororities. After the college pulled out of Irvington most of the campus buildings fell into disrepair. The dorm, which never had a name, was demolished in the 1930s. 

Sources:

George "Mac" Waller, Butler University: A Sesquicentennial History, Indiana University Press, 2006, pp. 158-159; Stem Brothers: Tornado--"Other Disasters, Indianapolis News, June 26, 1882, p. 4; Construction--"City News, Indianapolis News, August 26, 1882, p. 3; "City News," Indianapolis News, August 28, 1882, p. 1.

Wednesday, January 1, 2025

In Search of Herbert E. Fouts: Artist, Illustrator, Designer

      Nearly twenty years ago, I purchased a painting called Pool in Irvington (1921) from an online auction site. I knew little about the artist, Herbert E. Fouts, other than he studied at the John Herron Art Institute in Indianapolis. The small impressionistic painting has now traveled with me through three houses and currently hangs in the living room of my modest bungalow. The young artist who created the painting was likely in Irvington for no more than a few hours yet our worlds have intersected a century after his quick study of a beautiful scene. I mistakenly thought that there would be plenty of information on this talented painter, but I was wrong. My search for him metaphorically took me from Indiana to New York, Paris, Vienna, and back home. Who was Herbert E. Fouts? 

Pool in Irvington by Herbert E. Fouts, 1921

On the back of the painting, Fouts recorded exactly when he painted the scene.

Pool in Irvington hung in the 15th Annual Exhibition of Indiana Artists in the spring of 1922.


From New Washington, Indiana to the John Herron Institute (1902-1922)

Herbert E. Fouts rode in the backseat of this car in 1915. The older man in the photo is possibly his father, Isaac Fouts while the young man at the wheel is likely his brother, Arthur Fouts. (photo courtesy of Janae Tsu)

     Herbert E. Fouts started life on a farm in Clark County, Indiana near the village of New Washington in 1902. He was the second son of Isaac and Viola Fouts. Early on, his teachers noted that he possessed artistic talent. Later accounts reported that he used to fill the blackboards at the schoolhouse with "frescoes." Upon graduating from high school, he received the Clark County Scholarship to study at the John Herron Art Institute in Indianapolis beginning in the summer of 1921 and in subsequent terms in 1922. At some point during that first summer, he made his way to Irvington to set up an easel most likely near Pleasant Run. Local artist, William Forsyth, who taught painting and drawing at the Institute, might have been with him on that day. 

     Later that year, he submitted his work, Pool in Irvington, to the Art Association of Indiana for its 15th annual exhibition. Incredibly, he was chosen and appears to have been one of the few students accepted. The committee welcomed 134 painters, four sculptors, and numerous handicraft artists. Over 1300 visitors during the spring of 1922 strolled through the Herron Institute and admired work by talented artists like J. Ottis Adams, Simon Baus, William Forsyth, Marie Goth, Carl Graf, Paul Hadley, John W. Hardrick, Frederick Polley, Myra Reynolds Richards, Otto Stark, T.C. Steele, Clifton Wheeler, Hilah Drake Wheeler and many others. 

     Hanging on the wall that spring with so many of those great artists was Pool in Irvington. Bessie Hendricks, who also exhibited that year, wrote a column for the Indianapolis News. She mentioned numerous people in her review of the exhibition, but singled out young Herbert Fouts. ...Pool in Irvington, an attractive little oil painting in which the pool takes the leading role. There is not even a glimpse of the sky. Visitors were encouraged to buy paintings that day so it is possible that someone locally might have purchased the work; however, the provenance from 1922 until 2006 remains a mystery. 

Catalog of the Fifteenth Annual by Indiana Artists, April 22, 1922 (Image courtesy of Newfields Digital Archives) 

Herbert E. Fouts (middle row, second from right) was a design major while studying at Herron. One of his teachers was Paul Hadley (standing), who designed the state flag of Indiana. (Photo courtesy of the Herron Art Library Slide Collection, IU Indianapolis Library & Archives)

From Louisville to New York City: Herbert E. Fouts as an Illustrator (1923-1937)

     After studying at Herron, Fouts returned to southern Indiana. In nearby Louisville, he studied under Alexander Van Leshout, a local illustrator and muralist. The Louisville Courier-Journal  published some of Fouts' illustrations. By 1925, he settled in New York City and studied at the Parsons School of Design on scholarship. He earned a living by illustrating for magazines and publishers. He soon fell in with a group of Greenwich Village poets, who hired him to illustrate their books. By this point in his career, he seems to have moved away from Impressionism and into Art Deco. His illustrations for a book of poetry by Ralph Cheyney titled Touch and Go (1926) reflected his new interest in that genre. He quickly garnered other jobs with other poets including Sara Owens and Carolyn Davies. The Greenwich Village Quill, a magazine for that neighborhood, hired him to illustrate a cover in 1927. 

     In the summer of 1927, the young man sailed for Europe to study in both Paris and Vienna. Upon his return to New York City, he resumed his job as an illustrator. The Louisville Courier-Journal noted that his drawings were "ultra modern" and compared his art to the English illustrator, Aubrey Beardsley. 

   Fouts continued to get jobs as an illustrator in the 1930s including one by Jacob Krup who attempted to translate some of the work by the great Russian poet, Alexander Pushkin in 1936. One reviewer for the Fort Worth Telegram brutally panned the book, but praised Fouts. He noted that the illustrations were, "most attractive and more poetic than the printed matter of the book." 

Ralph Cheyney, Touch and Go, 1926

Ralph Cheyney, Touch and Go, 1926

Daggers in a Star, 1930

Jacob Krup, Six Poems from the Russian, (1936)

Herbert E. Fouts, Interior Designer, 1937-1970

     Like many Americans, Herbert Fouts likely struggled during the Great Depression, but those days would soon be in his rear-view mirror as his career soared to new heights. When he attended John Herron, Fouts was in the first cohort of design majors. One has to wonder if the idea of becoming an interior designer first germinated at Herron or did he arrive with that idea in mind? Throughout the 1930s, he decorated the homes of friends. Soon, his reputation as a designer spread and he opened a shop on 62nd Street in New York City in 1937 called Decorative Interiors. For the next thirty years he decorated homes for the wealthy. Band leader, Guy Lombardo, hired him to paint a Chinese screen for his home. Air-conditioning magnate, Willis Carrier, employed him to decorate a drawing room for his mansion in Syracuse, New York. Samuel Blackford, who owned a chain of cafeterias, contracted him to decorate his house. Fouts usually worked with their wives. 

     He was considered a very unique designer because he personally created the wall paper and any textiles for the project. He even occasionally designed the furniture. He painted the murals or added one of his own paintings. By the 1940s, he had become enamored with a new movement originating in New York City called abstract impressionism. He also worked with hotels. He painted a mural in the Park Lane Hotel near Central Park in New York City and decorated a rustic inn located in Westport, Connecticut. 

Donna Frazier was a first cousin, once removed to Herbert Fouts. She received a letter from him in 1956. (courtesy of Janae Tsu)

     Despite his success, he never forgot about his Indiana roots. After the tragic and untimely death of his brother, the responsibility for tending to his aging parents fell to him. He frequently flew home especially after his father died in 1949. He eventually moved his elderly mother into his New York City apartment. He visited both Louisville and Indianapolis and each time he spoke to reporters about design. In 1955, he gifted "October Moon" to his old high school at New Washington. The abstract impressionist work hung in the school for many years but its whereabouts remains unknown at this time. 

"October Moon" can be seen behind the young woman from this 1960s yearbook photo from New Washington High School (photo courtesy of the Greater Clark School Corporation)

"October Moon" is visible behind Gary Weston and Joan Moberly in this 1960s yearbook photo from New Washington High School (photo courtesy of the Greater Clark School Corporation)

     The best description that I found of Herbert Fouts came from Miss Mary Sample, a beloved Clark County, Indiana teacher. At the age of 80 in 1957, she traveled to New York City to visit with the successful native son. In classic Miss Sample form, she penned a letter to the editor to the Charlestown Courier to document what she had uncovered. She noted that his apartment was "beautifully decorated," and that he lovingly referred to his wheel-chair bound mother, Viola Fouts, as "Aunt Vi." Miss Sample toured his shop and revealed that Eleanor Roosevelt lived two doors down. She commented on the beauty of his textiles. They visited museums. They watched the Rockettes at Radio City Music Hall, and saw "Show Boat" on stage. Fouts put Miss Sample up at the Ellerton, a hotel for single women. She could hardly contain herself on all of the great food that they ate. 

     Herbert Fouts died in 1970.  Much of his design work has likely been replaced, but he would have understood that fact. Sometimes, it doesn't take long to be forgotten. There are still so many unknowns about the talented artist and creator. But, here is what we do know...In the summer of 1921, a young man arrived in Irvington and painted a scene.

Herbert E. Fouts, a successful painter, illustrator, muralist, and designer, posed on a New York City rooftop with his dog, Coco. (photo courtesy of Janae Tsu) 

     I wish to thank Art and Design Historian, Kyle Kingen for his assistance with this post. Kyle uncovered many obscure details including the photo of Herbert Fouts at Herron. He even examined Herron Art School records to confirm that Fouts was a design major. I also wish to thank Janae Tsu and her family for the use of the photos. Surprisingly, the only images I could find of Mr. Fouts were grainy newspaper shots. I am grateful for her kindness. Jonathan May and Nate Koets of the Greater Clark School Corporation took time out of their busy schedules to search for "October Moon." While the painting may be gone, I appreciated their help. 

Sources:  Early Years (1902-1922):  1910 and 1920 Federal Census Records, Herron Art School Enrollment Records, 1921-1922; Bessie Hendricks, "Comment on Indiana Art at Herron Institute and the Taos Society of Artists' Exhibition," Indianapolis News, March 11, 1922, p. 9

New York and Europe (1922-1937): "Youth Attracts Attention Here as Rare Artist," Louisville Herald, April 20, 1924, p. 65; "Herbert Fouts to Study in Europe," Louisville Courier-Journal, July 3, 1927, p. 6; "Local Artist Sails for Paris," Jeffersonville Evening News (IN), July 5, 1927, p. 2;  Catherine E. Berry, "Around New York," Louisville Courier-Journal, September 25, 1927, p. 9;  "About Books," Los Angeles Evening Post, July 31, 1929, p. 12;  "Drawings by Herbert Fouts," Louisville Courier-Journal, July 28, 1929, p. 36;  "Concerning Herbert E. Fouts," Louisville Courier-Journal, November 10, 1929, p. 37; Evidence of Inept Translation," Fort Worth Telegram, May 2, 1937, p. 44; 

Interior Design Years (1937-1970): Rhea Talley, "First He Did Over His Own Flat," Louisville Courier-Journal, September 7, 1947, p. 25;  "Fouts' Painting Featured at Art Exhibit," Jeffersonville Evening News (IN), June 25, 1955, p. 10; Mary Sample, Letter to the Editor, Charlestown Courier (IN), September 19, 1957, p. 4; "Art Adds to the Living," Indianapolis News, October 2, 1967, p. 14;